Arkansas bar exam case involves about 11,400 missing or inaccessible files
Reports support the approximate file count and charges against a former court official, but do not establish that the records belonged to Black applicants or that she removed every file.
The submission appears to refer to allegations against Nancie Givens, former executive director of the Arkansas Supreme Court’s Office of Professional Programs. The court’s statement confirms 65 public-record tampering counts involving alleged score changes and file deletion, while Reuters reports the court accused her of deleting or modifying approximately 11,400 files and electronic communications. Bloomberg Law reports that she pleaded not guilty; CBS Austin emphasizes that court personnel could not determine who performed the mass deletion or how. None of the supplied reporting identifies the missing records as belonging specifically to Black applicants.
What holds up
- ✓Multiple reports, citing the court’s review, describe approximately 11,400 electronic files as deleted, missing, or inaccessible; many concerned bar exam applications, applicant profiles, and scores.
- ✓An official November 5 statement confirms that prosecutors charged Givens with 65 counts of tampering with a public record.
- ✓Bloomberg Law reports that Givens pleaded not guilty, and the supplied material does not establish a conviction.
What doesn't yet
- ?The word “black” is unexplained. If it means records belonging to Black examinees, the supplied sources do not support that description.
- ?Responsibility remains disputed: Reuters reports the court’s accusation against Givens, while CBS Austin says court personnel could not identify who carried out the mass deletion.
- ?The submission presents an exact count and a settled act. Reporting uses an approximate count and distinguishes deletion from files becoming inaccessible or being modified.
Ask before you share
- →Does “black” refer to applicants’ race, or is it a mistake in the submission?
- →What evidence links Givens to the full set of roughly 11,400 affected files, rather than only some file removals?
- →How many files were actually deleted, how many were temporarily inaccessible, and how many were recovered?
Sources & original reporting
- [1]Arcourts · Accessed 16 Nov 2026 · arcourts.gov
- [2]Kark · Published 6 Nov 2026 · kark.com
- [3]Cbsaustin · Published 5 Nov 2026 · cbsaustin.com
- [4]News Bloomberglaw · Published 6 Nov 2026 · news.bloomberglaw.com
- [5]Atlantablackstar · Published 13 Nov 2026 · atlantablackstar.com
- [6]Katv · Published 6 Nov 2026 · katv.com
- [7]Reuters · Published 6 Nov 2026 · reuters.com